Federal Judge Rules DACA Illegal, Just As Obama Stated

Remember this?

(Heritage) President Donald Trump has caught a lot of heat for rescinding the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program with a six-month wind-down. Few people seem aware that he’s ending an administrative amnesty for illegal aliens that President Barack Obama lacked the constitutional and legal authority to implement.

How do we know? Because even Obama admitted it – repeatedly.

Responding in October 2010 to demands that he implement immigration reforms unilaterally, Obama declared, “I am not king. I can’t do these things just by myself.” In March 2011, he said that with “respect to the notion that I can just suspend deportations through executive order, that’s just not the case.” In May 2011, he acknowledged that he couldn’t “just bypass Congress and change the (immigration) law myself. … That’s not how a democracy works.”

And now

DACA Ruled Unconstitutional, Rescuing Dreamers Moves to Congress

illegal alien DemocratThe DACA program protecting from deportation hundreds of thousands of “Dreamers” who came to the U.S. as children has suffered a major blow, after a federal judge ruled that it was implemented unconstitutionally.

U.S. District Judge Andrew Hanen of Houston issued his ruling Friday in a suit brought by Republican-led states over the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which was implemented by the Obama administration on behalf of almost 650,000 Dreamers fighting to stay in the country.

“Although Congress may someday enact such a Dream Act, until it does, its continued failure to pass bills coextensive with the DACA population evinces a rejection of this policy,” Hanen said in a 77-page decision, which noted widespread sympathy for Dreamers. “As much as this court might agree with these sentiments, and as popular as this program might be, the proper origination point for DACA was, and is, Congress.”

None of the current Dreamers are set to be deported, and can acquire renewals, but, per the ruling, no new ones may be accepted. And the case goes to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, which is loaded with Trump appointees, and potentially going to the Supreme Court. No guarantee there

Hanen’s decision ultimately sets the case back on track to the U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled in June 2020 that Trump couldn’t arbitrarily end DACA without following federal rule-making procedures and providing a good explanation. The Texas challenge asked the same legal question in reverse, whether former president Barack Obama violated federal procedures when he implemented DACA without congressional approval in 2012.

Trump was ending a program that was un-Constitutional and outside the power of the Executive Branch. Why would he need any explanation other than that. It does show that he needed better lawyers, though, because they did a terrible job.

As one of his first acts, President Joe Biden signed an executive order for the Homeland Security secretary to “preserve and fortify” DACA, and the agency says it will undergo the formal rule-making process Texas claims Obama illegally skipped. The U.S. House of Representatives has also passed a bill to give all DACA recipients lawful permanent residency, and a bipartisan companion bill that protects Dreamers is under consideration in the Senate.

This is really about creating more Democrat party voters. And DACA rewards the parents who brought the kids here illegally/overstayed their visas. Illegal alien activists can call it all “cruel”, but, we either have laws or we rule by feelings.

Save $10 on purchases of $49.99 & up on our Fruit Bouquets at 1800flowers.com. Promo Code: FRUIT49
If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds.

Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed

2 Responses to “Federal Judge Rules DACA Illegal, Just As Obama Stated”

  1. est1950 says:

    Obama and Biden were presidents 30 years too early. Obama lamented this exact sentiment a few years ago in an interview. 30 years from now they could have willy nilly done what they wanted.

    Remember California used to be a solidly RED STATE. In 30 years it has turned into a socialist cesspool in which the Republican and independent voters have been rendered inconsequential.

    This is precisely what is happening in the USA. By fiat, Legislation, regulation and litigation the democrats are attempting to turn the USA into a larger version of California.

    Yes there are large swaths of the country that are RED but they are insignificant when it comes to power and the passing of laws and the changing of the mores of a country. It is why the battle rages for Texas today because the left has lost Florida.

    It is why Biden has ordered the military to FLY ILLEGALS from an air force base in Texas all over the country.

  2. est1950 says:

    In a more lighter note. The democrats are 1-13 in elections since Nov. 2020. They are even losing mayoral races in the suburbs of Dallas and Ft. Worth and in areas along the border that are 90 percent Hispanic.

    Hispanic voters are increasingly turning to the GOP just since last year as the full reality of what the Democrats want and have become is revealed to the world. These people fled authoritarianism and oppression. They fled socialism which basically is every country south of the Rio Grande to America where you are FREE to do what you want.

    Polls have Hispanics now in the low 40 percent range across the nation turning to the GOP and this number will only increase as the Democrats continue to implode with wokism.

    Especially since Hispanics and Asians are WHITE NATIONALISTS who must face their whiteness as it pertains to one of the most racist races on the planet. BLACKS. Even BLM is supporting CUBA when it fires on its citizens who only want to eat and are starving.

    They recognize as do the rest of the world that BLM is nothing more than a MAOIST Communist wing of the Chinese propaganda machine. Make no mistake, the people make a mistake of saying BLM is Marxist and they are not. They are Maoist trained which calls for a CULTURAL REVOLUTION along with MARXIST aspirations when it comes to the economy.

    Even the Democrats are admitting the BIG RED DOG is digging in their back yard. A quote by the way from 13 days A movie about the Cuban missile crisis with Kevin Cosner.

Bad Behavior has blocked 9907 access attempts in the last 7 days.