Should You Tell A Car Dealership What Your Monthly Budget Is?

This is always an interesting question, and, to start with, it very much depends on the dealership itself. Most dealerships cannot play too much, because then their surveys are going to be dogshit, and manufacturers do not like that, and have actually taken them away from companies. Now, I saw this at one of my fave sites, Caveman Circus (I’m going to italic it instead of blockquote, to keep their formatting to a degree)

Never tell a car dealership your monthly payment budget

Car dealerships love asking, “What monthly payment are you looking for?” It sounds like they’re helping you, but in reality, it’s a trap.

Why It’s a Bad Idea:

  • They’ll manipulate financing to meet your number while stretching out the loan term or inflating interest rates, so you end up paying way more over time.
  • They might add hidden fees or extras that seem minor when spread out over monthly payments but add thousands to the total cost.
  • It shifts focus away from the real number that matters: the total price of the car.

What to Do Instead:

  1. Ignore monthly payment discussions. Instead, ask: “What’s the out-the-door price?” (This includes taxes, fees, and everything you’ll actually pay.)
  2. Negotiate the total price first. Get it in writing before discussing financing or trade-ins.
  3. Once you have the best price, shop around for your own financing. Credit unions and banks usually offer better interest rates than the dealership.
  4. If financing through the dealer, negotiate the loan terms separately. Get them to match or beat your pre-approved offer

At times it makes sense, but, look, if you want to go this way you need to know a few things ahead of time, before going in. What’s your credit score? What kind of loan will your bank offer you, and for how much? What’s the rate? What car do you want? What’s the availability? Are there any upfront rebates/incentives from the manufacturer, and do they only apply if you finance through their bank? All of this can be done online before you head on it. Because, otherwise you could be seriously wasting your time, and the time of the rep. Not that most customers care about that.

Let’s say your budget is $500. The quick and dirty average is a $25000 vehicle with $0 down, because for every $5000 it is $100 of payment at 6.97% for 60 months. Things could get better or worse depending on credit and you could stretch the loan out. So, why the heck are you looking at a $54000 vehicle? Heck, even a $47K vehicle? Because that just happened on Saturday. And I straight up said they were either going to have to change their budget up drastically or go with a much higher mileage/older vehicle instead of new. It can’t be discounted enough, not with a 4-5% markup.

So the OTD price means jack if you are so beyond your payment. Just like buying a house, you need to know where your sweet-spot is. No Realtor will show you $600K+ homes when your budget is $350K tops. I’ll stay away from budget until a customer says enough stuff to force me to go there, and if you say $500 we won’t be driving $50000. Or $40K. Not unless you put a lot down. Because The Real Number drives the payment. Consumers need to learn this, and it is shocking how many have no idea, even older people.

On my screen, and most auto focused software, you see the price of the vehicle with everything (not usually finance office product, though), and you see payment. And I can show with downpayment so people can see the reality. Also using a mortgage calculator. One of the things we always say is 80% of the problems are caused by customers, often because they come in with unrealistic expectations. No real estate agent would put up with this. Try buying a boat this way. Or expensive jewelry. They won’t put up with it. These are things that should be taught, but, so often, you get stuff like the above which goes back to like the 50s, and creates problems for the buyers.

Save $10 on purchases of $49.99 & up on our Fruit Bouquets at 1800flowers.com. Promo Code: FRUIT49
If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds.

Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed

8 Responses to “Should You Tell A Car Dealership What Your Monthly Budget Is?”

  1. Zendo Deb says:

    I think it is perception, because you are selling them a car and a loan. Realtors send them off to a bank to get pre-qualified. Then they know the number is 350, not 600. And they aren’t usually selling a loan, though they have banks they work with.

    But then I don’t know why someone with a budget of $500 thinks they can drive a 50,000 vehicle. I guess math is hard.

    • Having the knowledge beforehand would seriously help buyers. The number of times it’s been like “so, if I get you to $28K out the door you’ll buy right now? Great. Done.”

      “I can’t afford that payment”

      “Well, you said $28K. That’s where your payment is. What about 72 months?”

      “Still too high”

      “Well, you need like $5K down to get there”

      And people often do not know their credit score, so, maybe the OTD works, but, not with a 540

  2. SD says:

    Red Wave? Republicans UP 3.1% over 2024 numbers in Swing State North Carolina!!

    https://commoncts.blogspot.com/2026/10/red-wave-republicans-up-31-over-2024.html

  3. Alias says:

    AIs response to trust worthiness of professions car salesmen were ranked 3rd from the bottom only ahead of telemarketers and Congress members ????

    • Some are shady, some are great. People think they are getting jammed in quite often, but, it’s literally what they asked for. And since many play these games they’ve been taught to play they think something nefarious is going on. Best thing is to do the research ahead of time, and understand what the money looks like. I’m literally dealing with someone right now who though she could get a $30K vehicle for $400 a month with nothing down. Math doesn’t lie nor work. Especially adding $3100 in negative equity.

      • alias says:

        Of course “some” are shady. But perception is reality and there is at least some truth in all stereotypes.
        Tell us what is your go to add on to increase the profit where you work? “paint protection” gotta have that if you want to keep the resale price of your ca up

        Gross profit per car at dealerships is around 2500 dollars
        Finance and insurance are 25% of dealership profits.

        Car buyers typically save a total of about 2000 dollars by using a car buyer agent

      • Professor Hale says:

        Whenever I want car-buying advice, I always consult someone who hasn’t owned a car in decades.

  4. Professor Hale says:

    Telling a car salesman your budget target isn’t important. It is a make believe number, not something carefully arrived at before you show up. The salesman will always try to upsell you no matter what you tell them, since getting more is their job. And it’s not like that dealer is the only one. Unless your car was recently wrecked and you don’t know how renting a car works and you need something today to get to work tomorrow (In other words, you are a crisis buyer), just be patient. Let the dealer play their games and if you get tired, walk away. It has been my experience that walking away is the only power you have and dealers will not take you seriously until you do. All a buyer has to do is recognize that there are thousands of suitable cars and hundreds of dealers to choose from, all in their area. There is no crisis. If they don’t see what they want, walk away and try again tomorrow… or next week.

Pirate's Cove