# Washington Post Suddenly Discovers This Thing Called Federalism In Differing Wuhan Virus Responses

- Link: https://www.thepiratescove.us/2020/03/18/washington-post-suddenly-discovers-this-thing-called-federalism-in-differing-wuhan-virus-responses/
- Published: 2020-03-18T08:05:02-04:00
- Author: William Teach

Why, yes, this is the way it is supposed to work. Different areas require different
responses. Heck, different parts of different states require different responses.
What’s needed for small parts of New York, such as NYC, Long Island, Buffalo, Albany,
are quite different than the rest of mildly suburban/rural NY.

> [**Across U.S., a vast disparity in responses**](https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/coronavirus-state-response-disparity/2020/03/17/854d2efe-6892-11ea-9923-57073adce27c_story.html)
> Mark Estee spent his Tuesday laying off 100 cooks, waiters and dishwashers, having
> been forced by city decree in Reno, Nev., to close two restaurants that had been
> thriving just days ago.
> Less than an hour down the road, in Nevadaâ€™s Carson Valley, the threat of coronavirus
> had inspired no such restrictions. Esteeâ€™s three other restaurants were preparing
> to serve dinner, a hearty mix of pasta, burgers and beer.
> Such is the state of Americaâ€™s patchwork response to the pandemic sweeping the
> globe. In some places, governors, mayors and county leaders have instituted aggressive
> action that is changing the fabric of life: shelter-in-place orders, business 
> bans and school closures. In other spots, authorities have been far more lax, 
> allowing routines to carry on more or less as normal.
> The divide in responses showed some signs of narrowing Tuesday: Nevadaâ€™s governor
> was reported byÂ [multiple news outlets](https://www.reviewjournal.com/local/local-nevada/sisolak-expected-to-order-closure-of-all-nonessential-businesses-in-nevada-1983950/)
> Â to be preparing to announce the shutdown of restaurants and bars late Tuesday
> evening. The governor of West Virginia did the same, and he appeared chastened
> as he announced that his state had become the 50th to record a coronavirus case.

I wonder what the other [eight states](https://www.liveabout.com/obama-quote-ive-visited-57-states-3298904)
will do?

> In states that had already taken tough measures, the response only escalated: 
> North Carolinaâ€™s Outer Banks announced it was setting up checkpoints to keep
> nonresidents out of the popular barrier islands. New Yorkâ€™s mayor said he was
> considering ordering the cityâ€™s nearly 9 million people to stay at home, as 
> San Francisco did a day earlier.
> But in other states, another day passed without the sort of robust action that
> public health officials say is needed to stem the virusâ€™s spread.
> The disparities across the country set the U.S. response apart from that of nations
> that have moved in a unified way to try to tamp down outbreaks. The gaps are increasingly
> drawing the ire of state and local officials who have acted decisively to halt
> the spread, but worry their efforts will be for naught if their neighbors donâ
> €™t follow suit â€” and if Washington doesnâ€™t act more proactively to set the
> tone.

This is federalism. It should work this way. The federal government can provide 
guidance, but, it’s much better of governments closer to actual people to look towards
policy. Los Federales have limited knowledge of what’s going on here in Raleigh,
nor in the more light suburban/almost rural area to the east. Even the state of 
North Carolina may not know as much. What is necessary for Raleigh could differ 
from, say, Zebulon and Wendell. Dare County, which is a big part of the Outer Banks,
has stated no one but residents, despite there being [zero known cases](https://www.wral.com/map-of-nc-us-coronavirus-cases/19010016/).
In fact, only a handful of NC counties have any cases, and it is Wake County, where
the capital city, Raleigh, is located (and an international airport) and Mecklenburg,
home of Charlotte and another international airport, have a bunch of cases.

There have only been 100 deaths so far. Compare that to the 20-40 thousand the CDC
estimates from the regular flu this year. Regardless, states also have different
Constitutions and statutes laying out their authority, for which the federal government
really does not have said authority. You’d think they would, but, no, theirs is 
extremely limited, and that was done on purpose. Most states make it tough for the
government to crack down, also on purpose. You can figure out why. Here in NC, the
Lt. Governor is questioning the [restaurant bans](https://www.wral.com/lt-governor-questions-validity-of-governor-s-nc-restaurant-ban/19016721/)

> Lt. Gov. Dan Forest questioned the validity ofÂ [Gov. Roy Cooper’s order Tuesday afternoon](https://www.wral.com/gov-cooper-closes-nc-bars-restaurants-adds-help-for-those-who-lose-jobs-during-coronavirus-crisis/19015964/)
> Â to shut down in-house seating at North Carolina bars and restaurants, saying
> the governor doesn’t have the authority to do it.
> Forest said the governor didn’t get concurrence from other Council of State members
> before announcing his decision Tuesday morning, failing to satisfy a requirement
> in the section of state law that lays out his emergency powers.
> “Thus, he does not have the authority to issue this part of his executive order,”
> Forest said inÂ [a statement posted to Twitter](https://ltgov.nc.gov/news/2020/03/17%20/lt-governor-forest-questions-validity-restaurant-ban)
> Â about 4 p.m.

It’s not that Dan doesn’t agree: he does, heard him say it on the radio. But, there
are laws in place.

> “It’s one thing to disagree, it’s another to create a chaotic situation in the
> middle of a pandemic,” Weiner said in a statement. “The governor is taking action
> to protect the health and safety of North Carolinians and does not need concurrence.
> The governor and the secretary of (the Department of Health and Human Services)
> have the authority to do this under state public health and emergency powers law.”

It’s dangerous applying power in this manner: where does it stop?

Anyhow, federalism.

### Share this:

 * [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)
 * [  Email ](https://www.thepiratescove.us/2020/03/18/washington-post-suddenly-discovers-this-thing-called-federalism-in-differing-wuhan-virus-responses/?subject=%5BShared%20Post%5D%20Washington%20Post%20Suddenly%20Discovers%20This%20Thing%20Called%20Federalism%20In%20Differing%20Wuhan%20Virus%20Responses&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.thepiratescove.us%2F2020%2F03%2F18%2Fwashington-post-suddenly-discovers-this-thing-called-federalism-in-differing-wuhan-virus-responses%2F&share=email)
 * [  Bluesky ](https://www.thepiratescove.us/2020/03/18/washington-post-suddenly-discovers-this-thing-called-federalism-in-differing-wuhan-virus-responses/?share=bluesky)
