# NY Times Circles The Wagons Over Virginia’s Infanticide Bill

- Link: https://www.thepiratescove.us/2019/02/01/ny-times-circles-the-wagons-over-virginias-infanticide-bill/
- Published: 2019-02-01T15:44:09-05:00
- Author: William Teach

Fortunately, and at least for the moment, the Virginia bill which would have codified
infanticide at the moment of birth has been defeated. Remember, these are the same
types of people who got all squishy over treating stone cold Islamic terrorists 
meanly. Babies, though? The Democrats are just showing their true stripes on the
issue. And along comes Michelle Goldberg in the NY Times, which has this as the 
featured opinion piece on the web front page

> **[Fake News About Abortion in Virginia](https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/01/opinion/abortion-virginia-kathy-tran.html)**
> UnderÂ [current law in Virginia](https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title18.2/chapter4/section18.2-74/),
> third-trimester abortions are permitted when a womanâ€™s physician and two other
> doctors certify that continuing a pregnancy would result in a motherâ€™s death,
> or â€œsubstantially and irremediably impair the mental or physical health of the
> woman.â€ This week Kathy Tran, a Democrat in Virginiaâ€™s House of Delegates,
> testified in favor of a bill that would end the requirement for two extra doctors
> to sign off on such abortions, and strike the words â€œsubstantially and irremediablyâ
> € from the existing law. Similar legislation has been introduced in past years.
> Despite what you might have heard, at no point did Tran try to legalize infanticide.
> When Tran appeared before a statehouse subcommittee, the Republican majority leader,
> Todd Gilbert, presented her with an outrÃ© hypothetical. Could a woman about to
> go into labor request an abortion if her doctor certified that she needed one 
> for mental health reasons? Tran said that the decision would be between a woman
> and her doctor, but, evidently taken aback by the question, eventually allowed
> that it would be permitted under her bill.
> Tran handled the moment poorly. She might have pointed out that legislation is
> not generally written with an eye to prohibiting ridiculous and unprecedented 
> scenarios. It is inconceivable that a doctor would certify a need for an abortion
> while a woman is in labor; some doctors wonâ€™t evenÂ [let a woman turn down a C-section](https://www.glamour.com/story/new-moms-c-sections-without-consent)
> Â if they think a babyâ€™s health is at risk. But Tranâ€™s impolitic answer to
> a ludicrous question gave abortion opponents grist for an explosion of self-righteous
> outrage.

Oh, she just “handled it poorly”, which is LibSpeak for “she told the truth.” The
vast majority of late term abortions are not to protect the mother: they are [elective](https://www.liveaction.org/news/three-myths-third-trimester-abortions/).
Exactly what was the need to change the existing law on late term abortions if not
to make it that much easier?

Michelle continues on for a bit, attempting to circle the wagons, ending with

> Having extra doctors sign off on each late abortion safeguards against (mythical)
> cavalier terminations, but it means that women in anguished, urgent situations
> need to jump through extra hoops. Abortion opponents treat mental health exemptions
> as easily exploited loopholes, but one instance in which theyâ€™re invoked is 
> when a woman learns that her fetus has little chance of surviving outside the 
> womb, and canâ€™t face the prospect of going through labor only to watch her baby
> die.

In other words, let the child die while it’s lying on a table.

### Share this:

 * [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)
 * [  Email ](https://www.thepiratescove.us/2019/02/01/ny-times-circles-the-wagons-over-virginias-infanticide-bill/?subject=%5BShared%20Post%5D%20NY%20Times%20Circles%20The%20Wagons%20Over%20Virginia%27s%20Infanticide%20Bill&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.thepiratescove.us%2F2019%2F02%2F01%2Fny-times-circles-the-wagons-over-virginias-infanticide-bill%2F&share=email)
 * [  Bluesky ](https://www.thepiratescove.us/2019/02/01/ny-times-circles-the-wagons-over-virginias-infanticide-bill/?share=bluesky)
